We sent an extra person to get the job done faster. It took longer.

Every job that runs over eats the profit you priced into it. Throwing more people at it usually makes it worse, and hides why it ran over.

We learned that the expensive way. Jobs were running over the time we'd allowed. The fix seemed obvious. Send another person so it gets done quicker.

It didn't get done quicker. Some jobs took longer. And now we were paying an extra wage on a job that was already losing money.

Does this ring a bell?

The crew rings at 2pm to say they won't be finished today. You'd quoted a day. It's going to be a day and a half, maybe two. You can't charge the customer for the extra time, because you gave them a price. So the extra half day comes straight out of your margin.

It happens once and you shrug it off. It happens every week and you start wondering where all the profit went.

What causes job overruns?

Usually it's one of four things, and most businesses have more than one.

  • The time allowed was never made clear. If the crew doesn't know how long a job should take, they can't aim for it. "As long as it takes" is a time, and it's a long one.
  • The prep wasn't done. Wrong gear on the truck, materials not ordered, no access arranged. The clock starts and nothing can happen.
  • The customer held things up. Waiting for a sign-off, a key, someone to move a vehicle. That's real time, and it isn't your crew's fault.
  • Nobody's checking. If allowed time and actual time are never compared, overruns become normal. Then they become the new standard, and you've priced for one time and you're paying for another.

Notice what isn't on the list. "Not enough people."

Does adding more people make a job faster?

Not as often as you'd think, and sometimes it makes it slower.

In 1975 Fred Brooks wrote The Mythical Man-Month about software projects. His conclusion became known as Brooks's law: adding people to a late project makes it later. The new person needs to be told what to do. Someone has to stop and show them. More people means more talking, more waiting for each other, and more people standing around while one person does the bit only they know how to do.

It's not just software. On any job, there's a point where another pair of hands just gets in the way.

And there's a bigger problem. When you send more people, you stop asking why the job ran over. The overrun gets hidden inside a bigger crew. You've paid for an extra person, and you still don't know what went wrong.

How much is a job overrun really costing you?

More than the extra wages.

Say a job is priced for two people for eight hours. It runs two hours over. That's four extra hours of wages, plus super, plus the vehicle sitting on site, plus the next job starting late. If it's a weekly thing across a few crews, it adds up to a wage you're paying for nothing.

Greg Crabtree, in Simple Numbers, Straight Talk, Big Profits!, says labour is the number to watch in a service business, because it's your biggest cost and the one that moves the most. His measure is how many dollars of gross profit each dollar of labour brings in. When jobs run over, that number drops, and so does everything below it.

Do jobs keep coming back to you to sort out? My free quiz, Why does everything still come back to you?, shows you which pattern is running your week.

How do you track job overruns?

You compare the time you allowed with the time it actually took, every job, every week.

Here's what we do now.

  1. Every job has an allowed time. It's set from years of doing the work. It's a standard, not a guess, and the crew is told what it is before they start.
  2. Actual hours get recorded. From clock-on to clock-off on that job, in the job software. If your team isn't using it properly, read 5 signs your team isn't really using your job software.
  3. Customer delays are recorded separately. If the customer held us up, we write it down. The allowed time doesn't change, because it's how long our work should take. The customer delay becomes a conversation with that customer.
  4. Once a week, someone reviews the overruns. Every job that went over, by how much, and why.

That last step is where most businesses fall over. The data's there, but nobody looks at it.

Who should be responsible for job overruns?

The person who runs the work on the day. Not you.

But here's the uncomfortable bit. If they've never been told the allowed time, never been shown the report, and never been asked why a job ran over, they can't own it. That part's on the owner.

It's COMMON SENSE to you that a two-person job takes a day. You've done it a hundred times. It isn't common sense to someone who's never been told. Write it down, tell them, and give them the numbers every week. Then it's theirs.

I wrote more about handing over properly in You delegated it. So why are you still doing it?

Why I care about this

I've run a business with staff for 22 years. We sent the extra person, and we paid for it. What actually fixed it was boring: a set time for every job, a weekly report, and someone responsible for reading it.

Overruns are usually where the profit goes missing. If you're not sure your jobs are making money at all, start with 3 signs your busiest jobs are your least profitable. For the bigger picture on cash, read The accountant said pay yourselves a bonus. There was nothing in the bank to pay it with.

What to do next

Take the quiz. Why does everything still come back to you? shows you which pattern is running your week, and gives you something to fix it with straight away.

Want help working through the rest? The BAR is where owners with staff come to work out what to fix first, find the time to do it, and get held to it. It opens in February 2027. Join the waitlist.

HI, I'M SAM

I've co-run a field service business for 22 years and served 12 years in the Navy. Now I help solopreneurs get the back-end stuff done, the money, systems, marketing and AI, so they get their weekend back.

NOT SURE WHAT'S SLIPPING?

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore.

+123-456-7890000

Newsletter

Subscribe now to get daily updates.

Created with © systeme.io